From the room

Stories after the pencil marks

These are sitters who agreed to be named with a short form of their surname. They describe a specific evening or a stack of returned charts, including the parts they would change.

I came in treating every signal-line cross as a reason to act. On evening three Niran made me leave the cross alone until the histogram had already started to shrink. I still argue with the pace — two and a half hours feels long when you want a rule written on one card — but the pencil marks on my own printouts are the part I use on Sunday evenings now.

Arun Phetprasert · MACD Confirmation Desk, March 2026

I brought three charts from a quiet month. Mali had already clipped them to the brass rail. We spent most of the hour on one zero-line touch I had circled for the wrong reason, and I left with two of the three pages crossed through.

Siriporn Kaewmala · Private Chart Sitting

The evening is only the histogram. Nobody asked what I hold. We counted bars that grew after the swing had already tired. I would have liked a printed glossary; they expect the words to stay in your notebook.

David Hargreaves · Evening Histogram Workshop

Week one came back with more red pencil than I expected, mostly where I had called a rising histogram 'confirmation' while price was already stalling. By week three the notes were shorter. The handwriting is small, and I had to sit under a lamp to read the margin, which I mention because it is true.

Lalita Boonmee · Marked Chart Follow-up after the January desk

Four Fridays and a thin margin

Lalita Boonmee finished the January Confirmation Desk and booked the follow-up because her own charts, once she got home, filled up with circles again. She brought the pages to Khlong Toei on four Fridays. The first came back with a red line through a rising histogram she had labelled confirmation while the ten-bar pace was already flat. She told Mali the notes felt harsh. Mali said the harshness was the point of paying for a second pair of eyes, and offered her the option to stop after week one with the refund set out for a single reviewed chart.

Lalita kept going. Week two was a currency chart where the cross sat far above zero; the margin said “wobble, not a change of lead.” Week three was shorter. The only sentence in the margin was “momentum agrees; write what cancels it.” She had forgotten the cancelling sentence, which the desk treats as part of the mark. At the forty-minute meeting she and Niran looked at the four pages in order. She left the crash-week chart she had wanted to discuss in her bag, because the month was about her marks, not about a famous week.

She still finds the handwriting small. She reads the margins under a lamp, and she has asked the academy to write larger. Niran has not changed his hand. That is the reservation she asked us to keep on the page.